You are reading

Morning 7 Train Delays Caused by Human Error, Not New System or Weather: MTA

File photo

Jan. 6, 2020 By Allie Griffin

Monday morning’s hellish rush hour commute for 7 line riders was caused by human error, not the expensive new signal technology or the light snow on the tracks, the MTA said in statement.

The first Monday morning commute of the new year became a nightmare for many Queens residents after the 7 train was severely delayed by a signal problem near the Grand Central – 42nd Street station.

Shortly after 7 a.m., 7 train express service was halted and overall service along the line between Queens and Manhattan was “extremely limited.” The MTA recommended commuters avoid taking the 7 train altogether soon after.

One commuter pointed out the irony that work was being done on the 7 line all weekend and come Monday, 7 trains weren’t working.

“Only the 7 train could have work done on it all weekend to then only not work come Monday,” the commuter tweeted.

But that work turned out to be the reason for the signal issue and resulting service problems, according to the MTA.

Workers incorrectly re-installed a transponder in the wrong location over the weekend, which caused the trains to not connect properly to the transponder.

“A transponder in an area of weekend track work on the 7 line that is designed to confirm the precise locations of trains was re-installed in the wrong location after work concluded before the morning rush hour,” said Sally Librera, Senior VP of Subways, MTA NYC Transit. “That caused trains to not connect properly to the transponder, resulting in slow speed operation as a safety precaution.”

Last month, 7 train service in Queens was delayed during a Wednesday morning commute because a dusting of snow interrupted the line’s expensive new signaling system on the raised tracks.

The MTA noted that today’s issue was not a weather-related.

“This was a case of human error, not weather or equipment, and was completely unacceptable to our customers and to us,” Librera said.

An unrelated switch issue caused morning delays on the E, F, M and R Queens Boulevard line which lead to more headaches.

“Because some riders had switched from the 7 line to the E,F,M and R, their trips were impacted twice,” Librera said.

She failed to note that the MTA advised passengers to take those lines to avoid 7 train delays — as well as the LIRR which was cross-honoring MetroCards.

Regular 7 train service did not resume until about 2:30 p.m.
“Teams of track workers were assigned to diagnose and resolve the conditions involved, and to eliminate impact on the afternoon rush hour,” Librera said. “They completed their work and after a period of testing for safety, regular 7 train service resumed at approximately 2:30 p.m.”
The MTA will conduct a post-incident review to evaluate contributing causes of the error to minimize future disruptions, she said.
email the author:


Click for Comments 

In the private sector, a contractor makes a mistake can be fired as you would expect some form of testing. This makes me wonder if the signaling depends on a transponder with no prior testing but it’s completely acceptable to allow trains to run come Monday? Thankfully, MTA and contractors are not in the airline industry or medical. Then when I have come across errors in hospitals, it’s no surprise patients have the wrong arm or leg operated on.


So now just finding out that the Q32 bus that runs from Jackson Heights( along Roosevelt Ave and then Queens Blvd ) to Penn Station is on of the bus routes that will be changed in this new redesign plan !!! The bus will now go up to 42 St & 5th ave . I work near MSG and this is the ONLY way I can commute to work since I have leg & knee injury . What do es the MTA expect me to do take like 3-4 buses ?? This is total madness especially there is a lot of housing construction on Roosevelt Ave & 51 St . Please I beg everyone NOT to let this go through !! This also applies to Q60- Bus driver was telling me they dont want buses along the # 7 line !!! .
This will be a nightmare.
I cant take train bc of the stairs.

Gardens Watcher

Weekend work during a holiday period no less. Guess the A team was still on vacation.


Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

Crunching the Queens crime numbers: grand larcenies down across borough, rapes halved in the north, robberies decrease in the south

Apr. 17, 2024 By Ethan Marshall

The number of grand larcenies across Queens was down during the 28-day period from March 18 to April 14, compared to the same period of time last year, according to the latest crime stats released by the NYPD Monday. At the same time, rapes and robberies decreased significantly in northern and southern Queens, respectively.