You are reading

Holden Blasts DOT for Not Incorporating Community Feedback Into Maspeth Citi Bike Plan

Citi Bike, Queens Plaza (Photo by Michael Dorgan, Queens Post, taken on March 16, 2022)

Citi Bike (Photo by Michael Dorgan, Queens Post)

June 27, 2022 By Christian Murray

The Department of Transportation plans to bring Citi Bike to Maspeth and Middle Village this summer but the agency is coming under fire from Councilmember Bob Holden for dismissing the community’s input as to the workings of the plan.

Holden, who penned a letter to Queens DOT Commissioner Nicole Garcia Friday, argues that the DOT is not paying attention to residents who have been calling on the DOT to preserve parking spaces by not putting the docking stations on the roadway.

The DOT announced February that Citi Bike was coming to the Middle Village/Maspeth area this summer and released a map that included 52 station locations, with as many as 34 stations to be installed on the street—likely to take as many as 100 parking spaces. The other 18 stations/docks planned are to be on sidewalks.

The Juniper Park Civic Association (JPCA), a local civic group, was alarmed by the DOT’s plan and the potential loss of parking. The organization, with the help of Holden, came up with a detailed proposal that called for the relocation of the 34 station/ docks planned to be placed in the streets to avoid any loss of parking.

The DOT notified Holden and the JPCA on June 22 that it had reviewed the organization’s suggestions and would make changes to seven of the stations—but the remainder of the plan would remain in place. (click for JPCA proposal and DOT response)

Holden was not pleased by the DOT’s response and fired off a letter to Garcia.

Councilmember Bob Holden (Photo: city council)

“I ask you to revisit your rejection of the Juniper Park Civic Association’s suggestions…,” Holden wrote. “Your response to our community’s suggestions seems dismissive, to say the least. Sadly, this is not a surprise.”

The DOT, in a letter written by Garcia to Holden on June 22, said it “took a hard look at each suggestion and where feasible incorporated changes into the updated plan.”

Christina Wilkinson, secretary of the Juniper Civic Association who drafted the proposal, said that the Maspeth/Middle Village community simply cannot afford to lose parking.

“We are a transit desert, and many people rely on vehicles,” Wilkinson said. “We don’t want residents and business owners looking for parking to be inconvenienced.”

“We want Citi Bike, but in a way that enhances our neighborhoods.”

The association’s plan would comprise of 43 stations in total, down from the DOT’s 52.

Wilkinson said that she put the plan together based on her knowledge of the area and after researching the DOT’s Citi Bike guidelines. She said her goal was to preserve parking spaces while making the bike share program a success.

Holden said that the DOT has not listened to local residents who he says know the area best.

“It is greatly frustrating to repeatedly meet with the DOT and have civic leaders and residents offer sensible solutions, only to be turned down each time,” Holden wrote. “The Queens DOT makes a show of community meetings but is indifferent or even hostile to real community input.”

“The options suggested by the JCPA seem very reasonable, well thought out and worth exploring.”

The JCPA’s plan calls for the elimination of 11 of the roadside stations. Wilkinson said many are not needed since the area isn’t as densely populated as other New York neighborhoods.

The DOT, however, said that the 11 were needed to ensure “equal access to the bike share network.” The DOT typically aims to have a station every few blocks within a coverage district. The idea is to have a station within a 3-to-5-minute walk from one another.

The DOT rejected about 15 other suggestions—that involve moving the stations to the sidewalk– on the basis that tree pits or fire hydrants were in the way or the sites weren’t big enough. However, Wilkinson argues the Citi Bike docks are modular and the size of the docks can vary according to the space.

She said that docks in other parts of Queens–such as Ridgewood–have been shorted or adjusted for obstacles. She points to a dock at Onderdonk and Willoughby Aves that makes room for tree pits.

The Citi Bike dock at Onderdonk and Willoughby Aves that makes room for the tree pits. (GMaps)

Holden says that Citi Bike stations can be tailored to the size of the space.

“If these bikes stations are adjustable in size, it seems they could fit quite well into the locations requested,” his letter reads.

“We are a public transit desert,” Holden wrote. “This makes parking more critical in this district than others. I am not at all opposed to expanding the program, but I ask you to show some deference to our community and not place the stations in parking lanes.”

Holden said that the DOT needs to listen to civic leaders and elected officials “since they know a neighborhood better than any citywide agency.”

Citi Bike draft plan for Maspeth and Middle Village as of Feb. 15, 2022 (DOT)

email the author:


Click for Comments 

Holden and Wilkinson are relics of the past. It’s bad enough Holden already funnels most of his council funds to Juniper Park, it’s another to criticize efforts to make CD30 better. It’s as though he conveniently forgets he’s a council member and not a civic association President anymore. He is right about one thing though, his district is a transit desert – specifically to the other areas of the borough that CitiBike will help serve. The community got what the community wanted, end of story.

John Maier

How is one Civic Association considered the spokesperson for all communities in Queens Community Board 5? And most importantly, why should Juniper Civic be the voice on this issue when the majority of the expansion is happening in parts of Maspeth (22 proposed stations in the original draft) that have always chosen to be their own civic [C.O.M.E.T] and not aligned with Bob’s Juniper Park organization, Ridgewood (17 proposed stations in the original draft) that has the Ridgewood Property Owners and Civic Association [RPOCA] and Farmers Oval Civic Associations that represent them, as well as Glendale (7 proposed stations in the original draft) that has the Glendale Property Owners and the Liberty Park Homeowners Association. Middle Village has a total of 4 locations being proposed in the draft, yet somehow they are the most aggrieved?

During the MONTHS of open comment members of our communities had ample opportunity to speak about the expansion –if you were being honest and actually paying attention– and I used the opportunity to speak in favor of using our public space for this expansion and I’m glad the DOT listened to this Ridgewood Resident! Also, I requested that sidewalks are impacted as little as possible by docking station placement since we are all users of that space, while the streets are where bikes and cars are the primary users so the their use for docking stations is most appropriate.

The Council Member likes to scream the loudest, but after a certain amount of time the squeaky wheel doesn’t always get the grease, sometimes it just gets designed around … and into obsolescence.

SPOT ON comments

Thank you for posting this!

Holden’s district is huge and served by so many different civic groups. This letter is on his letterhead and signed by the councilmember but reads as though it were written by JPCA. And of course it was! That’s simply not a council member’s job. He needs to represent ALL of his constituents.

Of course it’s not surprising in that he ran a narrow grievance campaign against a homeless shelter and has acted as a more of a culture warrior than an elected official. But gosh, what downgrade from one of the most talented politicians in recent Queens history. Five years without Liz and the signs of Holden’s neglect are really starting to show in D30.


So the DOT took the time to inspect every proposed location and incorporates 7 changes, saving potentially dozens of parking spots. This is a huge political victory for Holden…and this is how he reacts? Can’t wait for this nimby to be out of office for good.


Translation: “Crabby oldsters value nothing but aaaaaaaaaaaaaaarkiiiiiiiiing!”


Did the car people ask pedestrians, including those in wheelchairs or with strollers, whether they’d give up valuable sidewalk space to preserve some parking spots? Car people aren’t content until they have all the public space.


Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

AG James announces dismantling of Queens-based ghost gun trafficking operation

New York Attorney General Letitia James announced Wednesday the takedown of a prolific Queens-based gun trafficking crew accused of selling firearms and ammo at an East Elmhurst playground, the Queens Center Mall and other locations around the borough.

James secured a 625-count indictment charging five men for participating in the gun smuggling ring, which involved selling dozens of ghost guns, assault weapons, high-capacity magazines and hundreds of rounds of ammunition.