You are reading

Council Members Aim to Clamp Down on City Puppy Mills, Pet Stores

Dec. 23, 2010 By Christian Murray

Several New York City council members want the city to take on a bigger role in regulating and investigating puppy mills– which has traditionally fallen under the purview of the state.

Queens councilwoman Elizabeth Crowley, who has introduced a bill calling for greater city authority, says that she wants to reduce the number of “puppy-mill” dogs sold at pet stores by introducing a New York City “puppy birth certificate.”

The certificate would state the birth, breed, origin, color and any conspicuous markings of any puppy bought in New York City. The certificates would be filed with the city Department of Health.

Crowley’s new resolution also calls for the creation a citywide database of “puppy-mill” free pet stores. To earn such a credential, pet shop owners would need to apply to the city for a certificate by establishing that they receive their dogs from reputable breeders that comply with all applicable humane treatment laws.

“If you’re going to bring a dog into your family, you should know where the dog is coming from,” Crowley said at a press conference.

Sunnyside pet store owner, Steve Simone of Pets Unlimited, had heard about the proposal but had no comment on it.

Crowley estimates that 90% of canines in pet stores are the product of horrific living conditions inside puppy mills. The ASPCA estimates that 60% of the dogs in New York pet stores come from puppy mills in Missouri.

“These rules are a step in the right direction,” said Raja Shah, the owner of Dog Guru, a Sunnyside dog-rescue operation. However, he said that people shouldn’t buy dogs from pet stores, period.

If someone wants a pure bred (non-rescue) dog, they should find a breeder themselves. He said consumers should contact dog associations or industry professionals who know who the legitimate breeders are out there.

Meanwhile, City Councilman Peter Vallone Jr. this week also introduced a measure that would ban dog owners from tethering their pets outside for longer than three hours in a 12-hour period.

He said animals are “harmed mentally and physically” by being restrained for excessive periods of time.

Shah is a supporter of the measure.

“I see people going into stores and leaving their dog outside in 20 degrees,”  Shah said. “What are they thinking?”

email the author: [email protected]


Click for Comments 
Boycott Designer Dog Breeds

Hello, I am the creator of a new website called “Boycott Designer Dogs.” I would like to network with other website owners and bloggers who are involved in the animal advocacy arena to see if we can work together to implement some creative online activism strategies. I am really excited to discuss some of my ideas via email and to work with you and others to help educate the public, raise awareness and ultimately decrease the popularity of this designer dog trend. I have included a link to one of the pages on my site and would appreciate you getting in touch with me if you are interested in this at all. Thank you so much.


Pet’s Unlimited in Sunnyside is a HORRIFIC place. You walk in to a filthy, overcrowded space where puppies are stacked on top of each other, cages with no water, sickly cats and dogs and the dirtiest fish tanks I have EVER SCENE.

Please do NOT buy from this place!

Kevin Kolack

In addition to the pound, there are breed-specific rescue organizations. If you REALLY want that British Bulldog, or Maltese, or whatever, you can find one NOT from a pet store or a breeder. You just have to do a little work. We had a GREAT experience with the rescue group we went through. No one should ever buy from a pet store. There’s no reason. The employees may honestly believe their pets aren’t from mills, but they’re in denial.


Leave a Comment
Reply to this Comment

All comments are subject to moderation before being posted.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Recent News

LaGuardia’s new Terminal B wins major awards from two leading environmental organizations

Jun. 2, 2023 By Bill Parry

Not only is the finished product aesthetically pleasing to the eye that presents a vast improvement for traveler experience, the new $4 billion Terminal B at LaGuardia Airport is also a model of sustainability for such large-scale construction projects in the future. The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey and LaGuardia Gateway Partners, the developer and manager of Terminal B, on June 2 announced that the completed project has won prestigious awards from two leading international environmental institutions.

New York Hall of Science awarded federal funding for project on artificial intelligence

New York Hall of Science (NYSCI) will play a key role in the future of artificial and natural intelligence after U.S. Rep. Grace Meng announced that the institution in Flushing Meadows Corona Park has been awarded nearly a half-million dollars in federal funding from the National Science Foundation over the next five years.

NYSCI will be part of a $20 million initiative led by Columbia University to establish an AI Institute for Artificial and Natural Intelligence (ARNI), an interdisciplinary center that will bring together several top research institutions to focus on a national priority: connecting the major progress made in AI systems to the revolution in understanding the brain.