Landmarks Commission rejects Aluminaire House proposal

Print Friendly

25 Responses to Landmarks Commission rejects Aluminaire House proposal

  1. Frank Daykin

    That lot is an eyesore as it is, and has been for years. It is not used as a playground.

  2. Sunnysider

    They found Avonte’s body by the way.

  3. chris christies right hand man

    let me get this straight, a 1931 historic house doesn’t “fit” into a 1920s/1930s historic neighborhood…. but the creepy park is ok, everytime i pass the abandoned shack im thinkin jack nickelson will put an axe thru the wall and give me a “here’s Johnny!!”

    save the “historic playground” are you freakin serious!!??

    I guess its business as usual, if it aint jimmy friend it aint happenin

  4. Catherine

    Great news,so glad Landmarks defeated this proposal and did the right thing for Sunnyside Gardens.

  5. Sunnysider

    The Empire State Building is from the 30’s too, does it belong is Sunnyside gardens?

  6. a.bidge

    Whoever rejected this is a fking idiot. Time for the sunnyside dinosaurs to retire.

  7. Lunar

    Making it a park doesn’t sound so bad if we’re talking about one kids can play in.

    Skillman Park is a bit of a walk from that location so if its made into a park for kids to play in that’s less of a walk for parents.

    Restore what you can, replace anything that’s too worn to be used safely. Store balls and other park supplies in that shed. The spot that’s sheltered with the table would be a nice place for parents to sit and watch their kids. Maybe even make it a spot for kids to do arts and crafts and some days set aside for those activities. Maybe plant some bushes, grass and flowers inside the fence surrounding the property.

    That’s if they mean making it a park by what I’m thinking. Unless they mean for it to just stay as it is. Either way so long as that ugly looking building they wanted to put there isn’t going up. The thing looks more gaudy and out of place as the Storage buildings on 47th ave and near Northern Boulevard.

  8. Klunker

    It needs to be a small city park Van Bramer Park, whatever.
    Since moving here 20 years ago the place has been an abandoned horror set, how long does this take.

  9. Dorothy Morehead

    The entire project was flawed from day one. An aluminum structure, no matter its architectural or historical merit, would be inappropriate in the Sunnyside a Gardens Historic District.

  10. Breath of Fresh Air

    Thank goodness that Aluminum Albatross will not be outside my window! I’d like to see the land owned by the community. Make it an extension of Sunnyside Park, one that allows for adults and seniors to be members of the park community. Right now the only people who use that park are parents of small children, which is only one small segment of this community. Parks are for everyone!

  11. Patricia Dorfman

    Thank you landmarks commission

    and herb & liz reynolds, regina and all who coordinated the residents.

    and thank you to our elected officials who were outspokenly opposed, van bramer,

    gianaris and markey who went to hearing, and to nolan and crowley who also were vocal…cb2 chair joe conley who spoke out firmly

    hope the interesting little house gets a nice home, and that we get a park back by some means. kickstarter?

  12. Irving Douglas Estella

    But what to do with the abandoned park?

  13. Dorothy Morehead

    The playground not abandoned–it’s warehoused. Ideally, it will remain a playground. However, the owner may re-apply to the Landmarks Commission again to destroy the landmark structure and develop the property.

  14. Anonymous

    Kickstarter? Get real. The old timers talk a great game and have grand plans when it comes to other people’s property. They can’t even support the local restaurant scene.

  15. Celtic Bark

    Why does every square inch of land have to be “developed”?

    Why not just leave it be and let trees and grass grow as nature intended it? How about some breathing space for the people who already live here before cramming more people in?

    Enough of greedy real estate vampires.

  16. Relax

    @ Anonymous No matter where a property owner goes he is going to have neighbors who may or may not like his plans. This builder obviously doesn’t give a plug nickel for the residents here who have repeatedly stated their opposition to his plans. He got the place cheap and is trying to make an outsized profit off it no matter how he has to do it.

    This is a low-density residential place. We are not here to support business, business is here to cater to the needs of the community. You want big money? Go to Astoria. Oh, yeah, you can’t buy almost an acre of land on the cheap there.

  17. Reality Calling

    Bitter sweet. Im happy Landmarks said no to the A. House, but at same time I never liked the landmarking in the first place. BUT, its scary to think if this area wasn’t landmarked, that abomination (or worse) would have sidled in with no way for residents to dispute it.

    So, go landmarked area (last time I’ll ever say that).

    I still have an issue of placing terra cotta houses in the neighborhood. They simply don’t match our brick edifices.

  18. Anonymous

    @ Relax

    I can tell you’re not here to support business just look up and down Greenpoint and 43rd avenues.

    And I’m not above anyone turning outlandish profits, I’m sure most Gardens “elite” got theirs on the cheap… So not sure what that argument is about. There’s plenty of room for everyone, so tired of the whole “got mine, fsck you” attitude around here. Change is good and fresh blood should be welcome.

    Enjoy your abandoned lot I guess, I mean park.

  19. Anonymous

    @ Celtic bark

    Why don’t you move into the woods, as nature intended. Idiot.

  20. Craic Dealer

    Its a good thing these CHAVS were stopped. The Aluminaire House was just a ploy to get rental-housing on that corner.

    Sunnysiders are nice but they will defend themselves against greedy bastids.

  21. John Doe

    woohooo!!! fighting for the big wins!!! the park can remain abandoned for the next few decades!!! congrats!!! i can’t wait to move out of this insular neighborhood!

  22. Relax

    What in Heaven’s name is wrong with wanting to live in a quiet place? Calling people names because they like things quiet is stupid. I don’t want to live next door to a museum. If I did, I would have done all I could to move into Manhattan. I like the idea of being able to go outside on a nice day, enjoy what nature has to offer and meet my neighbors. As is it the only time I meet people is at the laundry mat.

    And most of the people I know do not own homes or condos. They are doing all they can to hold on.

  23. SuperWittySmitty

    So many comments on a topic that’s already been discussed to death. Let’s hope something good comes of all this and that space turns into something that its neighbors will find acceptable.

    Interesting how so many negative posts regarding empty storefronts on 43rd & GP aves, as if the fault lies with the residents of Sunnyside. Huge changes in the marketplace have taken place in the past generation and many of us shop differently than we did a few years ago. It’s hard for some of us to understand how so many business remain open! It’s cheaper for me to order (groceries, electronics, music, movies, hardware, soft goods, etc.) online and have it delivered to my door. Which stores do you think will be around in five years? Which shopping districts will thrive? Not the little guys, the independants, that’s for sure.

    I do try to buy food locally- glad to see the corporate version of pizza in town is suffering, while the real pizzerias keep selling those slices. The factory-food places keep offering deals in the windows (two “sandwiches” for $5!) but the real food places in Sunnyside continue to do well and I’m glad.

  24. Dorothy Morehead

    Well said, SuperWittySmitty.

  25. SunnyShade

    I am so happy to read this! Thank you Jimmy Van Bramer, Herb Reynolds, Nick Gulatta, Regina Shanley, Joe Conley, and all the elected officials who fought this. We must maintain the beautiful character of our neighborhood.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Latest News

Source: Pat O’Brien to Step Down as Community Board 2 Chair
May 5, By Christian Murray
Community Board 2 Chair Patrick O’Brien is expected to announce that he is stepping down from the top job at the board’s monthly meeting tonight, the LIC Post
has learned. O’Brien, who was elected as chair in December 2014 amid controversy,…
Lowery Bar & Kitchen Does The Big Reveal, But Still Waiting To Open
May 5, Staff Report
The construction shed has come down but the owners still have to wait before they can open. The owners of the Lowery Bar & Kitchen, the highly anticipated bar/restaurant located at the corner of 43rd Street and 43rd Avenue,…
Phipps Development “The Barnett” To Get Public Hearing In Sunnyside May 18
May 4, By Christian Murray
A public hearing is scheduled for May 18 where residents can voice their opinions on a 10-story, 200-plus unit development that is planned for 50-25 Barnett Ave. The developer, Phipps Houses, is seeking a zoning change in order to go ahead with the project,…
Bike Tour Will Explore Queens’ Jazz History This Saturday
May 3, By Michael Florio
Queens cyclists can take a ride through jazz history this weekend. The Queens Bike Initiative will host a bike tour through some of Queens’ jazz landmarks, such as the Louis Armstrong House Museum, on Saturday.…
Man masturbates on F train, police search for perpetrator
May 2, Staff Report
Police are searching for a man who allegedly masturbated while staring at a 26-year-old woman on the F train. The suspect sat on a Manhattan bound F train and at the Northern Blvd station masturbated while staring at the woman on Saturday between 10:30 pm and 11:00pm.…
Nine story office/commercial building to go up at 38-01 Queens Boulevard
Staff Report, May 2
Two real estate companies have teamed up to build a nine-story, mixed use building at 38-01 Queens Boulevard, The Wall Street Journal
reports. Curbcut Urban Partners LLC and Platinum Realty Associates have unveiled renderings for a 146,000-square-foot,…
Woman punched in the face on 7 train, suspect exits train at 46th Street Station
April 30, Staff Report
A 48-year-old woman was punched in the face on the 7-train Friday by another female rider who claimed the victim was staring at her, according to the NYPD. The suspect was involved in an argument with another rider as the train was approaching the 46th Street train station at about 3 pm.…
Burglaries Down Nearly 50 Percent This Year
April 27, By Christian Murray
The high number of burglaries has long plagued residents of Sunnyside/Woodside and Long Island City, but this year the number of reported incidents is down nearly 50 percent compared to the same period in 2015.…
New Yorkers need better transit. Here’s the way to get there
The city should have a majority of seats on the MTA board Opinion: By Jimmy Van Bramer
In 1968, the state took over New York City’s buses and subways and created the Metropolitan Transportation Authority. Nearly 50 years later,…


Elected Leaders to Hold Press Conference Friday to denounce Hate Crime ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Man Gets Jail time After Child Porn Found on his Computer By Best Buy Technician ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Parents Petition For More Pre-K Space After PS 78 Waitlist ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Source: Pat O’Brien to Step Down as Community Board 2 Chair ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Hundreds Sign Petition To Keep Local Yoga Studio In Business ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Outdoor Movie Lineup At Hunters Point South Park Announced; Series Kicks Off May 19 ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Shore Boulevard Revamp To Kick Off This Month ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Man follows woman into building, tries to push his way into her apartment ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Elementary School Planned for Parcel C at Hunters Point South ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Bike Tour Will Explore Queens’ Jazz History This Saturday ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Incoming Building In Queens Adds Height; Now “Supertall” ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Jackson Heights Yoga Studio to Close, Owner Struggles to Renew Lease ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Dromm: Queens Mall Should Remove Chick-fil-A Due To Anti-LGBT Funding ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Demolition Slated For Small Roosevelt Ave Property, New Development Likely ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

LIC Boathouse Kicks Off Season With Fundraiser at Alewife ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Playground With Nighttime Crime Problem Will Now Get Locked At 9PM ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Man masturbates on F train, police search for perpetrator ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

7 train rider robbed of cellphone at Queensboro Plaza station ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Three men assault man while yelling ‘Isis-Isis’ in Astoria Wednesday ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

Chick-fil-A To Open In Queens Center Mall This Fall ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

More Headlines

Woman punched in the face on 7 train, suspect exits train at 46th Street Station
April 30, Staff Report
A 48-year-old woman was punched in the face on the 7-train Friday by another female rider who claimed the victim was staring at her, according to the NYPD. The suspect was involved in an argument with another rider as the train was approaching the 46th Street train station at about 3 pm.…
Burglaries Down Nearly 50 Percent This Year
April 27, By Christian Murray
The high number of burglaries has long plagued residents of Sunnyside/Woodside and Long Island City, but this year the number of reported incidents is down nearly 50 percent compared to the same period in 2015.…
H&R Block Closes Queens Blvd Location
April 26, Staff Report
The H&R Block office located on Queens Boulevard has closed for good. The owner of the 44-03 Queens Boulevard office moved out Saturday and now the 1,500 square foot space is empty. Nelson Yadgarov, who is renting the space,…
Van Bramer Calls On MTA To Put Up Sound Barrier By LIRR Tracks
April 25, Staff Report
Councilman Jimmy Van Bramer and members of Community Board 2 will hold a press conference Tuesday to call on the MTA to follow through with its promise of putting up noise barriers next to the LIRR tracks on Barnett Avenue.…
Queens Anti-Gentrification Group Forms, Aims to Torpedo Phipps’ 10-Story Proposal
April 24, By Christian Murray
The quarter-page ad in Friday’s issue of the Woodside Herald
is direct: “Together we Stay, Stop the Phipps Development!” The ad was placed by a new group called the Queens Anti-Gentrification Project that was formed eight months ago by a handful of Sunnyside,…
Stop Sign At PS 361 Should Stay Permanently, Parents Say
April 21, Staff Report
Local parents are petitioning to keep the temporary stop signs near P.S. 361 in place permanently. About 100 people have signed a petition to retain the stop signs at 57th Street and 39th Avenue – an intersection described as vital for a safe passage to and from both P.S.…
Nonna Gina, a popular Sunnyside pizzeria, to close
April 19, Staff Report
Nonna Gina, the brick oven pizzeria that opened at 43-24 Greenpoint Ave. in January 2015, is likely to close, according to its owner. The pizzeria is currently owned by Simone Apollonio, who said the pizzeria had a short lease and that the landlord does not want to renew it.…
7 Train Will Get Two Additional Round Trips Per Weeknight This Fall
April 19, Staff Report
Crowded 7 train straphangers will get a little relief this fall. The MTA will provide two additional round trips on weeknights from 8 p.m. to 10 p.m. starting in the fall. The agency had mentioned the plan at a Sunnyside town hall meeting early this month,…
$1.8M In Winning Participatory Budget Items Announced
Five projects totaling $1.8 million, including several school upgrades, won this year’s Participatory Budgeting process in Council Member Jimmy Van Bramer’s district. Participatory Budgeting allows constituents to vote on how capital dollars will be spent in their district. More than 3,600 people came out to vote for this year’s session.…
The Starting Gate, a well-known Woodside bar, has been sold
April 15, By Christian Murray
The Starting Gate, which has been a popular Woodside bar for decades and a favorite among Irish immigrants, is being sold. Joseph Moloney, currently a bartender, is taking over the 59-10 Woodside Avenue pub along with two investors.…
Korean Fried Chicken Giant About to Open in Sunnyside
April 14, Christian Murray
A Korean fried chicken restaurant will be opening on Greenpoint Avenue this June. The establishment, called Pelicana, will be located at 47-08 Greenpoint Avenue, at the space that was formerly a hardware store. Pelicana, headquartered in South Korea,…
Local Comedy Fundraiser To Support Veterans
April 12, By Michael Florio
Sunnysiders can enjoy comedy for a good cause this month. Comedian Cory Jarvis, a Sunnyside resident, is hosting a comedy fundraiser for the Veterans of Foreign Wars on Saturday, April 30. The show will be held at the VFW Post located at 47-53 43rd St.…
New Queens Culinary Group Hosts Inaugural Event At Sunnyside’s Tangra Asian Fusion
April 11, By Michael Florio
The Queens Dinner Club, a new group aiming to showcase a different Queens restaurant each month, will feature a Sunnyside venue at its first event. The club will host its inaugural event on Thursday at 7 p.m.…
Woodside man nabbed by cops for his involvement in string of robberies, NYPD says
April 9, By Christian Murray
The police have apprehended a Woodside man who was allegedly involved in a robbery pattern that involved 16 stores in Queens and Brooklyn, including three in the Sunnyside and two in Woodside. The police had been looking for August Watkins who they have now charged with one of incidents but are investigating his involvement with others.…

In the Spotlight