Daniel Dromm’s view on “voting rights”

Print Friendly

11 Responses to Daniel Dromm’s view on “voting rights”

  1. get_to_the_point

    In other words, sneak in the country illegally and get to vote. Hey, can I hop the next plane to France or Mexico or just about any other country and get to choose their leaders too? I didn’t think so. Some politicians will do anything to scrounge up an election victory, American sovereignty and citizenship be damned.

    Like(0)Dislike(0)
  2. get_to_the_point

    Speaking of voting rights, how about the voting rights of NY State military personnel risking life and limb serving the country who were just disenfranchised out of their votes? Where’s the outrage over that? What about the voting rights of people in Nevada whose votes are being cancelled out in what looks like deliberate voter fraud. What about the voting rights of the people intimidated outside the polling station in Philadelphia in ’08 by baton wielding men?

    Let’s get out priorities in order.

    Like(0)Dislike(0)
  3. PatriotTours1

    Concilman Dromm, like many politicians today, is well meaning but does not fully understand the significance of “No taxation without representation”.

    This slogan was used by colonial Americans, subjects of King George III, against the British Crown in response to a series of taxes passed by the British Parliament, in which the colonies were not directly represented. (The Crown argued that the House of Commons provided them virtual representation.) These British subjects were CITIZENS of Great Britain and if they met voting requirements were able to participate in their local elections for assemblies and councils. Citizenship alone did not guarantee voting rights and as a result many colonists paid taxes levied by their local assemblies, but did not have the right to vote in elections for those assemblies.

    This was not a cry for everyone who paid any kind of tax to have the right to vote. It was a demand that the colonies be represented in the Parliament through their current election procedures. The closest analogy today would be if American citizens were able to vote in state and local elections, but unable to elect their federal representatives, who then voted to tax them for the federal government’s benefit.

    In the early 1800’s many states clarified their voting requirements. In NY all men of age who met a property requirement and had sworn an allegiance to the state were allowed to vote. In 1804 a citizenship requirement was added, but at that time the definition of citizen was still evolving in our new country and largely meant a citizen of the state. As time went on, further clarifications were made that generally allowed more people to vote. If states did not restrict voting on the basis of citizenship it was because the definition of citizen had not been fully established. This came with the ratification of the 14th Amendment to the Constitution in 1868.

    There is an easy solution to the dilemma these residents of the city face. Become a citizen of the United States of America as the many millions of immigrants did who made our nation great.

    Like(0)Dislike(0)
  4. Victor

    I would like to address some of the misinformation found in the comments of “get_to_the_point” and “PatriotTourist.”

    “In other words, sneak in the country illegally and get to vote.”

    Voting rights for LEGAL permanent residents and others here LEGALLY. Do you really think an undocumented residents are going to put their names on a roll of voters? Get real.

    “Hey, can I hop the next plane to France or Mexico or just about any other country and get to choose their leaders too? I didn’t think so.”

    Umm, actually there are a host of countries that recognize voting rights for all residents, not just citizens, at some level of government.

    “Some politicians will do anything to scrounge up an election victory, American sovereignty and citizenship be damned.”

    What are you talking about? How is American sovereignty and citizenship “damned”? You buying cheap goods from China is doing more to erode American sovereignty than is allowing local residents to have a say in running their city.

    “Speaking of voting rights, how about the voting rights of NY State military personnel ….”

    Again, what are you talking about? How do these issues affect allowing local residents to vote?

    PatriotTourist wrote: “These British subjects were CITIZENS of Great Britain and if they met voting requirements were able to participate in their local elections for assemblies and councils.”

    You are trying to give a history lesson, but you contradict yourself. The colonists were subjects of the British Crown, not citizens. There was not even the modern concept of citizenship at that time, as you yourself point out. As for the rest of your accoount, it supports Council Member Dromm’s use of the slogan “no taxation without representation.” He does not appear to be saying that the current situation is exactly the same as the late 18th century. The point is “if you pay, you should have a say.”

    “There is an easy solution to the dilemma these residents of the city face. Become a citizen of the United States of America as the many millions of immigrants did who made our nation great.”

    That’s what many are trying to do, but the process to become a citizen takes a LONG time. They should be able to vote in local matters in the meantime.

    Like(0)Dislike(0)
  5. steven

    Becoming a citizen should be a priority for anyone who has a genuine interest for the country they are residing in. It is difficult to learn a new language but being able to work hard and achieve citizenship carries more weight when it was accomplished by over coming difficulties. Anything worth having is worth working for.

    Like(0)Dislike(0)
  6. A Tarlow

    exactly, what is to point of becoming a citizen if legal aliens are granted all of the rights / privelidges of true citizenship. They should be applauded for going throught the rigirous process of becoming a US citizen & rewarded w/ voting rights once that (I’m sure quite long & tedious) process is complete. While they are awaiting citizenship legal aliens use public services (schools, roads, etc) like everyone else & should pay taxes.

    Like(0)Dislike(0)
  7. Time Flies

    @ A Tarlow

    You are 100% right.

    The process of becoming a citizen is long and tedious. They play by the rules, pay the fees, wait patiently, deal with surly bureaucrats and respect immigration law. It is a slap in the face to these decent men and women every time some hack politician lets someone jump the queue in front of them or give away something they spent years honestly trying to earn.

    Like(0)Dislike(0)
  8. PatriotTours1

    “The colonists were subjects of the British Crown, not citizens. There was not even the modern concept of citizenship at that time, as you yourself point out.”

    Would you argue, then, that today’s subjects of the British Crown are not citizens of the United Kingdom? We now use the terms interchangeably, even if they did not then, which was what I was doing in my post.

    “As for the rest of your accoount, it supports Council Member Dromm’s use of the slogan “no taxation without representation.” He does not appear to be saying that the current situation is exactly the same as the late 18th century. The point is “if you pay, you should have a say.””

    You must not have read my post thoroughly. Most people in the colonies did not have the right to vote in local elections yet recognized that their colonial assemblies passed laws governing their behavior. In NY to vote one had to be a free man with either an estate valued at 40 pounds or more or a free man who practiced one of many recognized trades. Slaves, indentured servants, tenant farmers, women, and others did not vote yet did not object to the authority of their local assemblies. There is absolutely no historic precedent for people to vote in local elections without some type of restriction.

    In addition, those voting requirements encouraged newcomers to become landowners or tradesmen, which added to the prosperity of the colony.

    “That’s what many are trying to do, but the process to become a citizen takes a LONG time. They should be able to vote in local matters in the meantime.”

    How would this be managed? A period of time that one can vote until becoming a citizen? And if one does not become a citizen, what then, are the votes cast during that time rescinded?

    Although I do not agree with it I have no objection to the phrase “if you pay you should have a say”, only to equating it to early protests over taxation.

    Like(0)Dislike(0)
  9. Thomas Quinn

    I have noticed that almost every post on this page is an undereducated gesture of some form or another. A company called Pearson Operating for the government out Lawrence, Kansas is Prime example of how hard they have made it to get citizenship in this country and those who meet the requirements are being neglected on waiting lists that stretch out for years to come.

    America’s colonies and the Pioneers who started this country were formed by immigrants that befriended the Native people of WHAT IS ONLY OUR COUNTRY TODAY and then slaughtered them in a violent abuse of power.
    Had they not first been befriended the Indians, starting with the pilgrims they would have been thrown back to the shore and arrowed off, not even knowing what hit them.

    History proves nothing any of you can say with too much pride will hold any true value: get_to_the_point and Victor are prime examples, need I elborate? Remember there is a big difference between immigrants and illegal immigrants. So just Remember that. Many immigrants without citizenship come here to go to college and end up making babies and starting busnesses.

    I have a long list of books you should go read, none of which have any political meaning.

    This is off the subject but the corporate world has surpressed free energy devices so we keep having to pay to fill ther pockets. Perpetual motion home generators exist today and for every one part enery input five parts energy output is produced.

    What is water??? H2O: Hydrogen and oxygen, two very explosive forms of gas that when when burned together turn back into water.
    With electrolysis, hydrogen and oxygen can be separated and power a vehicle for up to 100 miles per gallon at 26 times more powerful than any petrolium we can produce. Stan Myer a very healthy and brilliant inventor/Genious was poisoned in 1998 by arab oil companies that offered him over a billion for his water powered car. He said no way this is for the people. What a shame that even Arabs have more power than we do in our own country.

    If we want to make a real change, those of us entitled to vote should put a stop to these corporations controling the energy in this country. That, I believe, is a great place to start making a difference cause I’m calling bullishit on the ethics of this country, especially in the medical world where a poor familily doesnt even have the option of getting their dying son on the waitlist for a transplant even if they find a perfect match.

    Like(0)Dislike(0)
  10. Hopeonhorizon

    Councilman is a typical demagogue whose only goal is to stay on the City Council. For that he’ll do and say anything, it seems. Without any regard to our laws. That’s coming from a first generation immigrant, who came here legally, 20 years ago, and waited for his citizenship to get the right to vote.

    Like(0)Dislike(0)
  11. me

    I never heard a more inept, absurd and outrageous proposal in my entire life. I am European citizen, legally coming and residing in the US/ NYC. Over my lifetime I never heard any nation or party in a nation to make such proposal. In Europe one would end up in prison just for making such claim! I hope Americans will understand the insanity of the Democratic Party and will vote different in 2012 too! If no consider moving to Canada or EU for life in NYC is already bellow any standards because of illegals!

    Like(0)Dislike(0)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Latest News

OPINION: CB 2 “Discloses” Joe Conley’s Status But Many Questions Remain
Opinion: Sept. 1, By John O'Reilly
I received on August 31, 2015 an email from CB 2 forwarding documents regarding Joseph Conley’s appointment to the Board’s Land Use and Transportation Committees and the draft minutes of the Board’s June 4,…
Big block party planned for Skillman Ave
August 31, By Christian Murray
Two of Sunnyside's leading business groups are hosting a large block party on Skillman Avenue next month that will bring bands, dancers and local restaurants together for the day. The event, dubbed “The Skillman Avenue Fall Festival,” will take place on Saturday,…
Opinion: Our Community Board is Violating State Law
08-20-15 JOR to CB 2 re pending Conley FOIL requests…
7 line extension complete, Hudson Yards station opens Sept. 13
August 28, By Michael Florio
The MTA has announced that it will be opening its highly-anticipated 34th Street/Hudson Yards stop on September 13. The stop is about a mile from the Times Square-42nd Street station and is located at 34th Street and 11th Avenue.…
Sunnyside residents start petition drive in opposition to 10-story building proposal
August 26, By Christian Murray
The developer that plans to construct a 10-story, 220-unit residential building on Barnett Avenue (near 52nd Street) is about to face some heavy resistance from Sunnyside residents who are dead-set against the project. Phipps Houses,…
Sunnyside/Woodside’s small businesses hit with fewer fines in 2015
August 25, By Christian Murray
The amount of money New York City has been collecting in fines from western Queens business owners has dropped significantly in the past year as the City continues to shed its ‘gotcha’ inspection culture.…
Man shot in broad daylight in Woodside
August 25, By Jackie Strawbridge
A 60-year man was shot in the arm while he was driving his vehicle in Woodside this afternoon, according to police. The victim was shot by a man who was walking on the sidewalk near 62-35 30th Avenue at about 1:15 pm,…
Two eateries open on 46th Street
August 24, Staff Report
A Thai restaurant and a Mexican-American diner have opened on 46th Street in the past two weeks. Term Tem, a Thai eatery, opened at 45-53 46th Street 10 days ago, taking over the space that was previously occupied by the Chinese restaurant China Taste.…
Police release sketch of suspect wanted for acid attack
August 23, Staff Report
The police have released a sketch of the suspect believed to have thrown an acid-like substance into the face of a woman on Skillman Avenue Wednesday. The suspect--described as  5' 8", black and about 30 years old--allegedly threw a hazardous liquid into a 59-year-old woman’s face outside 33-02 Skillman Ave.…

More Headlines

Man shot in broad daylight in Woodside
August 25, By Jackie Strawbridge
A 60-year man was shot in the arm while he was driving his vehicle in Woodside this afternoon, according to police. The victim was shot by a man who was walking on the sidewalk near 62-35 30th Avenue at about 1:15 pm,…
Two eateries open on 46th Street
August 24, Staff Report
A Thai restaurant and a Mexican-American diner have opened on 46th Street in the past two weeks. Term Tem, a Thai eatery, opened at 45-53 46th Street 10 days ago, taking over the space that was previously occupied by the Chinese restaurant China Taste.…
Police release sketch of suspect wanted for acid attack
August 23, Staff Report
The police have released a sketch of the suspect believed to have thrown an acid-like substance into the face of a woman on Skillman Avenue Wednesday. The suspect--described as  5' 8", black and about 30 years old--allegedly threw a hazardous liquid into a 59-year-old woman’s face outside 33-02 Skillman Ave.…
Murphy’s closed, shut down by court order
August 20, By Christian Murray
Murphy’s Bar, located at 48-18 Skillman Avenue, closed for good Wednesday. The establishment was shutdown by the landlord who took possession of the space by court order. A marshal’s notice was posted on the front door of the bar/restaurant that was filed by the landlord against Murphy's and proprietor Mike Murphy.…
Woman attacked with acid-like substance on 43rd Avenue
August 20, Staff Report
A 59-year-old woman was seriously burned after a man threw a hazardous substance in her face near Sunnyside last night, according to police. The woman was getting into her car at the corner of 43rd Avenue and 33rd Street at about 5:35 pm when the man approached her and tossed an unknown substance into her face,…
Well-known Woodside building on the market, site likely to be developed
August 19, Staff Report
A large piece of Queens Blvd real estate is for sale--being marketed as ideal for hotels and condos. The property, located on the corner of Queens Blvd and 60th Street, is on the market for $4.5 million and is currently occupied by a laundromat,…
Masked man breaks into Pearle Vision on Queens Blvd, quickly nabbed by cops
August 18, By Christian Murray
A masked-man who smashed through the glass door at Pearle Vision and scooped up more than $3,000 in glasses was stopped in his tracks by police as he attempted to flee the store early Saturday,…
Pesticide spraying to take place across sections of Sunnyside/Woodside tonight
August 17, By Christian Murray
Trucks will be spraying a number of western Queens neighborhoods with a pesticide this evening as the Health Dept. aims to deplete the mosquito population to combat West Nile disease. Spraying will begin at 8:30 pm,…
Yankee fan on ATV takes it for a spin around Sunnyside
August 16, Staff Report
A man dressed in a Yankee shirt was riding through the streets of Sunnyside yesterday on an all-terrain vehicle. The rider drove down Skillman Avenue, made an illegal right turn on 43rd Avenue and then raced to Northern Boulevard.…
Bliss Street Station, a long-time Sunnyside bar, to close
August 14, By Christian Murray
Bliss Street Station, an Irish bar/restaurant that has been part of the neighborhood since 1989, is closing. Ambrose Gurhy, a co-owner of the 47-02 Greenpoint Ave. establishment, said the bar’s last day will be Sunday,…
Man struck by 7 train on Woodside platform, looking in wrong direction
August 14, By Michael Florio
A Flushing-bound 7 train struck and injured a man who at the Woodside station this morning. The man was leaning over the edge of the platform and was looking in the wrong direction when the incoming 7-train struck him at 8:28 am,…
Italian restaurant to open on Queens Blvd
August 13, By Christian Murray
A new Italian restaurant is opening on Queens Blvd. Zio Luigie, a restaurant that will focus primarily on offering fresh pastas, is scheduled to open at 42-15 Queens Blvd in October, according to owner Louis Bermjo.…
Caffe Bene’s Sunnyside operation is for sale
August 11, Staff Report
Caffe Bene’s Sunnyside operation is for sale. The café, located at 41-31 Queens Blvd, opened in May 2014 and is on the market for $550,000 (click for listing). The rent is $7,000 per month and there is 15 years left on the lease,…
Car Sharing Network Expands into Western Queens
August 11, By Jackie Strawbridge
A car sharing company hopes to better connect Brooklyn and Queens by expanding its network into the borough. Car2Go, an international car share company with a fleet of vehicles in Brooklyn, announced Tuesday that it will expand to Long Island City,…

Restaurants